• About
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Contact

Piano Music Chords QA

Find popular and new piano chords to play everyday.

  • Home
  • Ask
    • Ask Your Question
  • Answer
Home » piano chord inversions pdf » What do you think of my first sonata?

What do you think of my first sonata?

Q. I'm looking for criticisms on my harmony and my modulation to the dominant (It sounds funny and I don't know how to fix it). Attached is a pic of all the music because I can't attach a .pdf. This is about grade 4/5 so it's good sight reading practise for anyone that wants it. Any other comments would be helpful too... Thanks!

Link:
http://i218.photobucket.com/albums/cc189/DaraJava/Untitled-1.jpg

P.S. Sorry but some bars got smushed towards the end. Blame Finale!
Why is everyone attacking maninkia? Please stop using my question as a forum to have petty battles. Thank you.

Also, i. jones, your links don't work. Could you re-post them please? Thanks.

A. Some random jottings from a former lecturer in composition....
(i) Your modulation to the Dominant sounded queer merely because you sat on a chord in its second inversion, a weak sound almost always!
(ii) You chose to write in the style of C.P.E.Bach (A style about 250 years old now). Any sensitive listener would hear this, and subconsciously demand that you followed the practices of this long-gone era. You didn't.
(a)There are several very naked consecutives, and there are at least two obvious and weak similar motion passages to an octave or to a fifth. When there is never more than 2 notes sounding simultaneusly, this is awfully exposed.
(b) On more than one occasion you give us harmony with no third or 7th, merely a perfect interval (4th, 5th, or 8th). This provides no harmonic 'grit' whatsoever.
(c) Apart from my comment on the reason your modulation sounded amateurish, there is, from memory, two other occasions when you use the 2nd inversion of your accompanyment chord. In the thin texture you have chosen, this almost always sounds a little weak.
2. The work seems to start again every 4 bars. Did you mean it to?
3. Although you have a well-developed melodic sense, and you use dissonance quite nicely, I felt there was a need for the movement to be 'about' something. It seemed to be a pretty piece of almost nothing. Is there a theme? Already,I have forgotten it, if there was!

The above seems quite harsh, no doubt? There are far more good things than bad in your first attempt to write music, and I wish you well in your future writing.

Do you think the 18th Century Alberti bass is viable in the 21st Century? I don't. Srely there is nothing new to say in that idiom, and, with the development of the modern piano, the need for this style of writing is long gone!

A tinkling little piece of pretty salon writing is not to be scoffed at. I'm sorry if you think that's what I was doing. I was trying to encourage you to write more forcefully, to attempt to 'say' something in your future efforts.

Already, you use Finale really well!

Original Question




Powered by Yahoo! Answers
Posted by KickAnswers on - Rating: 4.5
Title : What do you think of my first sonata?
Description : Q. I'm looking for criticisms on my harmony and my modulation to the dominant (It sounds funny and I don't know how to fix it). Att...

Share to

Facebook Google+ Twitter
Newer Post
Older Post
Home

Popular Posts

  • What are the piano chords for "Transatlanticism" by Death Cab for Cutie?
    Q. I play a little bit of piano, and I really love that song. All I am looking for is the names of the piano chords used in the song, the c...
  • What are some upbeat and happy chords for the piano?
    Q. My friend and I are trying to compose a song and can't find any good chords. Preferably in the key of C. A. The major chords are g...
  • How do you transcribe or arrange music?
    Q. For people who do this, how do you do it? I think its near impossible for me to listen to something and write it down in a sheet of musi...
  • The most difficult you've played?
    Q. Mine was Sonata Facile. God, the piece's so brittle and transparent! I have played a lot of other pieces that are supposed to be A L...
  • How can I play chords like Em7 or Dm7 on the piano?
    Q. I'm playing piano and well I just have no idea how to play chords like Gm7 or just G7 or Em7 or Dm7 and etc. To make it much easier ...
  • Piano chords to go with alto sax piece?
    Q. I'm playing colours of the wind on alto sax in the C Major key... I need three piano chords that i can play to accompany this, but I...
  • can you learn to play the piano at any age to a good standard?
    Q. I have developed a love towards piano music, and would like to take up lessons, however my friend is a pretty good piano player, and she...
  • How long would it take to be a Grade Eight pianist?
    Q. I'm eighteen and I just started taking piano classes. I have some experience with the instrument and I really, really want to master...
  • Easy popular songs to play on piano?
    Q. I need a good popular song to play on the piano with vocals, im of a fairly good standard its just that im not all that patient. I don...
  • HOW TO FIND PIANO CHORDS?
    Q. A. This one is my favorite: Encyclopedia of Picture Chords for All Keyboards (Paperback, 1996) Author: Leonard Vogler Original Question...
Copyright © 2012 Piano Music Chords QA - All Rights Reserved
Powered by Blogger